{
  "kind": "recorded-numerical-kerr-reference-check",
  "preparedOn": "2026-10-31",
  "massScaleNominalSolarMasses": 68,
  "declaredSpins": [
    0.4,
    0.5,
    0.6,
    0.68,
    0.69,
    0.7,
    0.8,
    0.9
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "spin": 0.4,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.43984192173538716,
        "damping": 0.08688196202939837,
        "quality": 2.5312614463434726
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.44218237654750725,
        "damping": 0.08736715484016475,
        "quality": 2.5305984689352936
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.00532112719698441,
        "damping": 0.0055845056837253715,
        "quality": -0.0002619158163755797
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.37753219176433,
        "spin": 0.40043523132487346
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.5,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.4641230259759384,
        "damping": 0.08563883498806402,
        "quality": 2.709769615856089
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.4673934238967669,
        "damping": 0.08639579920877653,
        "quality": 2.704954570576428
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.007046403082354491,
        "damping": 0.008839029872580895,
        "quality": -0.0017769205365230079
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.57537045290631,
        "spin": 0.502397733519406
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.6,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.4940447817813842,
        "damping": 0.0837652021610409,
        "quality": 2.948985790254344
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.4974518829312169,
        "damping": 0.08456881153568653,
        "quality": 2.941107211381947
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.00689634072755041,
        "damping": 0.009593594403326078,
        "quality": -0.002671623206335405
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.59741317457504,
        "spin": 0.6028032136550214
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.68,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5239751042900839,
        "damping": 0.08151262363119956,
        "quality": 3.2140733603471485
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5266561249456173,
        "damping": 0.08215971982843083,
        "quality": 3.205074981057636
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.005116694731452709,
        "damping": 0.007938601021591829,
        "quality": -0.0027996807417427494
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.46817470521769,
        "spin": 0.6822911564953804
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.69,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5282207863216013,
        "damping": 0.08116228777249598,
        "quality": 3.2541023720415816
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5307432852920579,
        "damping": 0.08177666270192789,
        "quality": 3.245077921720726
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.004775463283114512,
        "damping": 0.007569709360017551,
        "quality": -0.0027732533550238747
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.44199138523582,
        "spin": 0.6921911524816533
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.7,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.532600243551018,
        "damping": 0.08079287315500766,
        "quality": 3.296084312592655
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5349469124275706,
        "damping": 0.08137155514262744,
        "quality": 3.2870633447395705
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.004406060464611672,
        "damping": 0.007162537548448533,
        "quality": -0.0027368741201855284
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.41349701611179,
        "spin": 0.7020854357683122
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.8,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5860169749088703,
        "damping": 0.07562955235606142,
        "quality": 3.8742591794667898
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5854819404013166,
        "damping": 0.07569827167891938,
        "quality": 3.867208110673172
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": -0.0009130017225812415,
        "damping": 0.0009086305646028858,
        "quality": -0.001819978599002292
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 68.00067580361362,
        "spin": 0.8008893187739344
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.9,
      "mode": "220",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.6716142721321627,
        "damping": 0.06486923587579592,
        "quality": 5.176677843239064
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.6659711958308377,
        "damping": 0.06433254877228997,
        "quality": 5.176005059181584
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": -0.008402257866572782,
        "damping": -0.00827336866636652,
        "quality": -0.00012996444396451423
      },
      "fundamentalMap": {
        "mass": 67.4320314230371,
        "spin": 0.9000301152544913
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.4,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.4208466772299829,
        "damping": 0.26473344900189016,
        "quality": 0.7948498363479904
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.42317307252152736,
        "damping": 0.2670848549641515,
        "quality": 0.7922071668540064
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.005527892739600082,
        "damping": 0.008882164196200915,
        "quality": -0.0033247405649927675
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.5,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.44740703745320193,
        "damping": 0.2602245536370362,
        "quality": 0.8596556919783398
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.4507847883055255,
        "damping": 0.2637509803370213,
        "quality": 0.8545651427143742
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.0075496149357661135,
        "damping": 0.013551475641702115,
        "quality": -0.005921614096744521
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.6,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.4798066652457193,
        "damping": 0.25384686453491656,
        "quality": 0.9450710886754365
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.4834822337755032,
        "damping": 0.2575602878320873,
        "quality": 0.9385807063756321
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.007660519946928179,
        "damping": 0.01462859627584634,
        "quality": -0.0068676127939761855
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.68,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5119411472039396,
        "damping": 0.24652857506304715,
        "quality": 1.0382998138715074
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5150131705758804,
        "damping": 0.24953377727682477,
        "quality": 1.0319508168317857
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.006000735414059211,
        "damping": 0.012190076598662225,
        "quality": -0.006114801288510496
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.69,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5164815243283037,
        "damping": 0.2454115611164624,
        "quality": 1.0522762700718946
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5194070103810201,
        "damping": 0.2482695353716405,
        "quality": 1.0460546631376006
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.0056642608010442075,
        "damping": 0.011645638217597343,
        "quality": -0.005912522320653424
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.7,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5211607652680377,
        "damping": 0.24423831581238747,
        "quality": 1.0669103320962325
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5239211590600525,
        "damping": 0.24693574777103075,
        "quality": 1.0608451060432416
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": 0.005296626254271519,
        "damping": 0.011044262034280106,
        "quality": -0.005684850798168051
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.8,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.5779223971672046,
        "damping": 0.2281489400416384,
        "quality": 1.2665463119437037
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.5777947104185358,
        "damping": 0.22855358679270812,
        "quality": 1.2640245959967802
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": -0.00022094099362590658,
        "damping": 0.0017736078501870978,
        "quality": -0.001991017559439756
      }
    },
    {
      "spin": 0.9,
      "mode": "221",
      "reference": {
        "real": 0.6676575508183809,
        "damping": 0.19525206705561526,
        "quality": 1.7097323497942953
      },
      "approximateFit": {
        "real": 0.6620430725003285,
        "damping": 0.1929288905131962,
        "quality": 1.7157696567353793
      },
      "fractionalErrors": {
        "frequency": -0.00840921863486821,
        "damping": -0.011898345443673741,
        "quality": 0.0035311415507872645
      }
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "title": "Gregory B. Cook, numerical Kerr modes, version 3",
      "url": "https://zenodo.org/records/14024959"
    },
    {
      "title": "Cook and Zalutskiy, numerical method",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.90.124021"
    },
    {
      "title": "Berti, Cardoso and Will, approximate fits",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0512160"
    }
  ],
  "method": "Two published numerical modes at eight declared native spins. No interpolation. Compare the approximation at the same mass and spin. Algebraically match the fundamental frequency and damping for the parameter-map example.",
  "limits": [
    "The parameter map matches two noiseless spectral properties; it is not a strain-fit bias estimate or an observed mass.",
    "The calibration study generates and fits with the same approximation; it does not test this physical approximation error.",
    "Numerical Kerr spectra still assume Kerr and linear perturbations; they do not validate merger excitation, onset, nonlinear effects or detector noise.",
    "No new local Teukolsky solve, overtone detection, GR test, discovery novelty or production-pipeline advantage follows."
  ],
  "credit": "Comparison and presentation by Aptifold’s AI agent; numerical spectra, their method and fit coefficients retain the cited scientific credit. Paul Wishall set the goals and reviewed the results."
}
