THE MISSING SIGNAL FIELD NOTE 02
Can one more reading find the cart?
Help a warehouse team find one missing cart. Its radio tag sends a signal to receivers, which report distance without direction in this example.
A and B report 5 units each. Both places fit.
Move receiver C, then allow reading error. Can the team rule out one location?
No hidden true location.
Two possible locations for one cart
ONE SQUARE = ONE UNITBoth places are 3 units from C. This position cannot tell them apart.
C is the receiver you move. Its colored lines show the distance to each possible cart location. The triangles stay fixed.
FIRST, DESIGN THE MEASUREMENT
What would C read in each case?
Drag the dashed line to test a report. Moving C keeps that number. Dots mark distances; bars include the allowed error.
Hypothetical report: 3 units ↓Both places fit
Same place in the reading scale.
C is three units from both places. Another reading here cannot tell them apart.
A bound you choose for this exercise, not a probability.
THEN, TEST A POSSIBLE REPORT
Where would this reading send the team?
Pretend C has reported a distance. Enter that made-up number below. A location still fits if its bar includes the number, including at the endpoints. Can the team rule out one location, or do both remain possible? Moving C changes the predictions, not the reading you enter.
Enter 0–16 in steps of 0.1. No real measurement or hidden answer is being revealed.
C REPORTS 3
Both places still fit.
This checks only the two places left by the exact A and B readings.
Why these ranges work, and what this model leaves out
Keep the assumptions in view.
Indoor asset-location systems are a real application of ranging: tags and anchors exchange signals to estimate distance. Qorvo’s technical introduction describes warehouse asset tracking. Our cart story is an invented geometry example. It leaves out radio timing, reflections, obstacles and errors in A and B; it does not plan a warehouse installation.
A is at (3, 6), B at (11, 6), and each reports exactly 5. Subtracting their squared-distance equations gives east = 7. Then 4² + (north − 6)² = 5², so north is 3 or 9. These two places remain points because we have allowed no error in A or B.
Station C stays at east 7. Its distance to a place is the absolute difference in their north coordinates. If that distance is d and C’s declared error bound is e, a permitted report runs from max(0, d − e) to d + e, endpoints included. Two touching ranges still permit one shared report.
Separating these ranges makes C informative only if the actual error stays within the declared bound. A report outside both ranges conflicts with these assumptions; it does not tell you which assumption failed. Increasing the bound can restore compatibility without proving that a reading was accurate.
This is a fictional flat geometry exercise with no measured data, probabilities or geographic coordinates. It does not calculate a general noisy search area, calibrate an instrument or provide navigation or emergency advice.
Allow error in all three readings and inspect the shared search region →